“Plaintiff Was Hypersensitive,” DePuy Lawsuit Defense Witness States

Posted by Sarah Showard | Apr 24, 2013 | 0 Comments

 e2 80 9cplaintiff 20was 20hypersensitive  e2 80 9d 20depuy 20lawsuit 20defense 20witness 20states

Expert defense witness testimony in DePuy lawsuit could deal a devastating blow to the plaintiff's case.

The jury in the second DePuy hip implant lawsuit to go to trial (Carol Strum v. DePuy Orthopaedics, Inc. et al, case no. 2011-L-009352) has recently heard testimony from an expert witness for the defense alleging that:

  • The plaintiff was likely hypersensitive to a normal amount of debris shed from the DePuy ASR XL metal-on-metal hip implant.
  • The device, upon inspection after it had been removed, did not display evidence of excessive wear.
  • The plaintiff's specific physiological and biological issues, rather than the alleged defective design of the DePuy hip implant, necessitated that the implant to be removed during revision surgery.
  • The DePuy ASR XL hip implant should still be used in patients today.

This testimony could prove crippling to the plaintiff, who is contending that the defects with DePuy's metal-on-metal hip implant caused an excessive amount of metal debris to be shed in her body and ultimately required her to undergo invasive and risky revision surgery. One of the key points of the case is proving whether or not the DePuy hip implants were, in fact, defective.

Although DePuy metal-on-metal hip implants were first introduced as an innovative device that could improve mobility in patients requiring hip replacement surgery, as reports that patients with these implants required revision surgery mounted, DePuy eventually issued a voluntary recall of its ASR XL metal-on-metal hip implants in August 2010. Since then, more than 10,000 DePuy hip implant lawsuits have been filed nationwide by patients alleging serious injuries due to the defective design of these implants. Whether the jury in this case is swayed by the defense expert's testimony regarding the alleged safety of these hip implants could prove to have important repercussions for future DePuy lawsuits to go to trial.

If you or a loved one has been injured and you believe that the injuries were caused by a defective or dangerous product, contact the experienced Tucson product liability lawyers at the Showard Law Firm. For more than 20 years, we have been standing up for victims' rights and helping them win the compensation they deserve. For a free evaluation of your case and professional advice regarding the best manner in which to move forward, call us at (866) 307-2147.

About the Author

Sarah Showard

Sarah Showard graduated from the University of Maryland in 1985, Magna Cum Laude with a Bachelor of Arts in English-Linguistics and a Certification in Womens Studies. She then graduated from New York University School of Law in 1988. Sarah began practice initially as an insurance defense attorne...


There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Showard Law Firm-Tucson's Local Law Firm for defective drug & medical device claims.

Showard 20staff 202017 201026 20special 20edit edit.jpg 20small

Showard Law Firm is dedicated to compassionate representation for our clients who have been injured by defective products, dangerous drugs or the negligence of any individual or company. We are experienced in litigation and ready to ensure you receive the maximum possible settlement for your injuries, medical bills, mental anguish and other losses.

Sarah Showard and Dr. Peter Ott - 2018 Heart Ball Chairs


Sarah and Peter are the proud chairs of this year's Heart and Stroke Ball, held on 2/17/18 at the El Conquistador. With a western theme "Heart of the West", this important fund raiser is in its 60th year, all raising funds to help with research and advances in the case against heart disease in the Tucson community.